
Joe Gideon necks Dexedrine, runs an audition, argues with his editor, and collapses — repeatedly, across the whole film — and each time the sequence is cut with a violence you don’t expect from a musical. Bob Fosse made All That Jazz about a man very like Bob Fosse, a director-choreographer burning through amphetamines and cigarettes to finish a Broadway show while his heart quietly gives out. He was not being subtle. He was reportedly recovering from his own heart surgery while making it. The film knows exactly what it’s confessing to.
The Cutting Is the Choreography
The reputation this film has earned rests on its editing, and it deserves every word of it. Alan Heim won the Oscar, and watching the film you can see why: the cross-cutting between Gideon’s hospital bed and the numbers happening in his head does something musicals rarely attempt, which is to make the cutting itself feel like it’s dancing. Numbers don’t just start — they’re assembled out of fragments, rehearsal footage bleeding into fantasy, a heartbeat on a monitor setting the rhythm of a cut. The ‘Airotica’ number is the one people remember, all restraint and sweat and disapproving producers watching from the back of the room, and it earns the discomfort it’s going for.
Roy Scheider, not a trained dancer, plays Gideon with a chain-smoking exhaustion that never asks for sympathy. That’s the film’s nerve: it doesn’t soften its stand-in for a man treating his body as expendable and everyone around him as collateral. Gideon is genuinely good at his job and genuinely cruel to the people who love him, and the film refuses to pick one of those and drop the other.
Who This Is For, and the Slow Patch
This is for anyone who wants to see what a musical can do with grief and self-indictment rather than uplift — it’s closer to a fever than a night at the theatre, and if you know how it’s heading (the film doesn’t hide it, and neither will this), the tension is in how, not whether.
The honest reservation: the middle section drags. There’s a long stretch of hospital politics and producer negotiations that exists mostly to delay the inevitable, and it’s the one place the film’s nerve slackens into ordinary backstage drama. It’s necessary groundwork for the ending’s assault of an ending, but it asks for patience the first hour doesn’t.
Watch it for the cutting, for Scheider refusing to be liked, and for a film that treats its own maker’s mortality as material rather than metaphor. It is not comfortable. It was not trying to be.
Newsletter
Musicals worth the evening
Get The Showstopper in your inbox. No spam, and one click to leave.
Weekly, on Mondays · Unsubscribe any time. We never sell or rent your address; read the privacy policy.